This weekend was my Fall Break, and I took advantage of the time at home with my mother to get her help with making a from-scratch pumpkin pie.
For as long as I can remember and probably before, my mom has always used the “meat” of our Halloween jack-o-lanterns to make delicious pumpkin pies. Because of that, I always cringe when I see people waste good pumpkins by letting them rot on their front porches, and then go out and buy pumpkin in a can to make their pies. It’s irresponsible environmentally and perpetuates the stereotype of wasteful Americans who throw away good food when people in other parts of the world are starving. So I wanted to do my part and conserve and utilize all the parts of my jack-o-lantern.
My first order of business was of course to buy a pumpkin. I took my 6-year-old nephew to a local grocery store to help me pick one out. We had been sent with instructions from my mom to get one that was short, fat, and really orange; she says that the taller and “more yellow” a pumpkin is, the less the taste.
After we found one according to her specifications, we followed it up by buying a dozen eggs and two cans of condensed milk. We were supposed to get the unsweetened kind, but Mom had neglected to tell us this because she assumed it would be obvious. It wasn’t, so we ended up having to compensate a little bit later on.
Once home, my nephew described the kind of face he wanted drawn on his jack-o-lantern, and I tried to follow his instructions as best as I could. He decided on large “ghost” eyes and a mouth with lots of little pointy teeth.

My nephew showing off his scary Halloween face and the jack-o-lantern
The next item on the agenda was to hull out the pumpkin. I went in prepared with the knowledge that this would be laborious, but I was still a little exhausted by the end.
First, I cut a circle around the top of the pumpkin, making sure to give it a “lip” so that the top of the jack-o-lantern would fit back on without falling in. Then, I pulled all the seeds and goopy strings out by hand. This was a little gross, but the hard part was trying to detach some of the strings from the inside walls and floors. I used my hands, a large metal spoon, and a knife.

Seeds and goopy stuff that doesn't go in the pie
Once that was done, I had to find a way to remove the good, inside layer of the pumpkin for cooking. I initially used a knife, trying to cut big chunks from the inside “walls.” Because of the curvature and the small hole, though, that failed pretty quickly. So, instead, I took the big metal spoon and scraped it from the bottom of the inside wall to the top over and over again, all the way around. This left me with piles of tiny shredded pieces. I ended up with enough to make about three pies.

The "meaty" part of the pumpkin that I scraped from the inside
The next thing that I did was put the pumpkin scrapings in a pot on the stove on low heat. My mom explained that this was to “break it down” from the strings. After the pumpkin turned a bright yellow and was mushy to the touch, I used a mixer to create something with the consistency of chunky applesauce.

Cooking the pumpkin to break it down from the strings
While this was cooking, I took some time to cut out the jack-o-lantern for my nephew. I would like to point out that this is another good reason to use the pumpkin “meat”—cutting out the face is a lot easier when the pumpkin is thinner (the walls have been shaved from the inside).
Then it was time to add milk to the pot, and that’s when we found out I had bought the wrong kind. My mom insisted that it would be okay, that we would just add some skim milk with it to compensate. However, I added too much. Because I had been insisting on doing everything by myself because this “was my project,” she didn’t realize my mistake for several minutes. The mixture was too thin, she said, so we’d have to add some canned pumpkin to even it out.
I admit, I was pretty dejected by this. I had wanted to do everything completely on my own and completely from scratch. But I guess that mistakes are part of the process, and I’ll know better next time.
I was also getting a little frustrated with my nephew at this point. Now that the fun jack-o-lantern part was over with, he was bored. And when he’s bored, he bounces off the walls with that endless supply of energy that all kids that age seem to have. At any other point I would have been fine with his antics, but I felt that since I was going to be reporting on my cooking to the world, I needed a little bit more space to concentrate. So I recommend putting the pumpkin in the refrigerator for a while until peace and quiet can be had, because the noise added to my stress level considerably.
After we added a can of already-mashed pumpkin to the pot of hulled pumpkin, we added some brown sugar, pumpkin pie spice, corn starch, vanilla, and three eggs. I would give a more detailed recipe, but this is my mom’s secret formula to a perfect pumpkin pie, and she doesn’t feel like sharing.
While all of that was kept on very low heat, I started to make four pie crusts (because of the can, we now had enough mix for one more pie). I took a can of Crisco All-Vegetable Shortening and scooped out one and a half cups of it to add to four cups of all-purpose flour. Two teaspoons of salt were also added. Then, I had to use my hands to mix it all together until it “was the consistency of cornmeal”—this was my instruction. For those of you who don’t know what that is, like me, the closest thing I can describe the texture to is tiny, soft beads.
Then I added 10 tablespoons of water. Again, I mixed it all in with my hands, and stopped when it felt like Play-Dough. I had to continue to add a tablespoon of water each time I went back to make a new crust.
I took a piece of this dough that rolled into a ball with about a two-and-a-half inch diameter. I rolled this ball around in flour, and then began to flatten it on wax paper with my hands. After it was as flat as I could make it doing that, I took a rolling pin (covered in flour so it wouldn’t stick) and made a thin, flat circle. The edges of this circle had a tendency to shred, so I had to constantly pinch them together. Also, I had to occasionally sprinkle more flour on the dough.

Rolling the dough to make a crust
When it was flattened to my mom’s satisfaction, I put a pie pan on top of it upside down. Then I carefully slid my hand under the wax paper and flipped the whole thing over. I cut the edges of the crust to fit the pan, and then made “ruffles” on the rim for aesthetic purposes. Finally, I ladled the pumpkin into the crust and browned the crust in the oven at 425° for 15 minutes. Then, I covered the crust with aluminum foil and baked the pie at 350° for 45 minutes.
I repeated all the steps for the crust three more times.
This, as you can probably tell, was not easy. It was probably harder for me than the sewing was, even though the sewing took longer and was more tedious. I don’t know if it was because the process is harder, or if it was the stress of having my mom watch what I did and critique things, and my nephew being a typically loud child. I think it was probably a little of everything. But I had less fun with this project that I had with the other two. However, it was good to do some bonding with my family anyways.
The pies are wonderful and I’m really proud of myself. Also, this is probably a life skill that will come in handy more often than the sewing or the canning will. So it was very worth my while, and I’m extremely glad that I know how to do it.

One of the four pies after it was baked
As a side note, there’s a really good way to make use of the pumpkin seeds too. You boil the seeds in saltwater for ten minutes, and then put a layer of them in the oven on a baking sheet with olive oil until they brown. The temperature should be about 400°. When they’re done, they’re nice and yummy, like sunflower seeds.